The concept of manners and etiquette is often associated with politeness, respect, and social grace. However, beneath the surface of these well-intentioned customs lies a subtle yet powerful tool for division and disempowerment. In a society where the rules of propriety are not universally understood or adhered to, manners can be wielded as a weapon to exclude, marginalize, and disenfranchise entire segments of the population.
.png)
What are manners, truly? They are a set of unwritten rules, social codes, and behavioral norms that govern how we interact with one another. These codes are deeply rooted in cultural traditions, socioeconomic status, and societal hierarchies. While they ostensibly serve to create a sense of order and civility, they are also inextricably linked to power dynamics and the reinforcement of existing social structures.
The Roots of Manners: Class, Culture, and Power
The origins of modern etiquette can be traced back to the aristocratic courts of Europe, where intricate codes of conduct were developed to distinguish the noble classes from the commoners. These rules dictated everything from how one ate and dressed to the proper way of addressing those of higher social rank. This system of manners was not merely about politeness; it was a means of reinforcing the existing power structures and maintaining the elite's privileged position in society.
As these codes of conduct spread beyond the confines of the nobility, they became intertwined with the emerging bourgeois class. The ability to adhere to certain standards of etiquette became a marker of social status and refinement, separating the "civilized" from the "uncultured." This perpetuated a cycle of exclusion, where those unfamiliar with the intricate rules of propriety were branded as uncouth and unworthy of social acceptance.
The Cultural Divide: Whose Manners Matter?
In a multicultural society, the notion of universal manners is a fallacy. Each cultural tradition has its own set of behavioral norms, many of which may conflict with those of the dominant culture. This clash of etiquette creates a divide, where those who adhere to the dominant culture's standards are perceived as "polite" and "well-mannered," while those who follow different cultural norms are often labeled as lacking in manners.
This dynamic is particularly evident in the realm of education and professional settings, where the rules of propriety are heavily influenced by the dominant culture. Students and employees from marginalized backgrounds may find themselves at a disadvantage, as their cultural norms are perceived as inappropriate or ill-mannered within these environments. This can lead to discrimination, exclusion, and a sense of alienation, effectively disempowering those who do not conform to the accepted standards of etiquette.
The Subtle Art of Exclusion
One of the most insidious ways in which manners can be used as a tool for division and disempowerment is through subtle, often unconscious, acts of exclusion. These can manifest in seemingly innocuous ways, such as the use of complex jargon, dress codes, or specialized dining etiquette that are unfamiliar to those outside the dominant cultural group.
For instance, a formal dinner event may require knowledge of intricate table manners, from the proper way to hold cutlery to the order in which courses are served. Those unfamiliar with these conventions may find themselves feeling out of place, self-conscious, and ill-equipped to participate fully in the event. This subtle sense of exclusion can be profoundly disempowering, eroding confidence and reinforcing the notion that one does not truly belong.
The Burden of Code-Switching
For those who navigate multiple cultural spaces, the burden of code-switching – adapting one's behavior, language, and mannerisms to conform to different environments – can be immense. Individuals from marginalized backgrounds often find themselves having to adopt the dominant culture's norms of etiquette in professional or formal settings, while simultaneously adhering to their own cultural traditions in other contexts.
This constant shifting between different sets of manners can be mentally and emotionally taxing, leading to a sense of inauthenticity and fragmentation of identity. It also reinforces the perception that one's own cultural norms are somehow inferior or inappropriate in certain spaces, further perpetuating feelings of disempowerment and marginalization.
The Weaponization of Manners: Shaming and Social Ostracism
Perhaps the most overt way in which manners can be used as a weapon is through the act of shaming and social ostracism. Those who fail to adhere to the expected codes of conduct may find themselves subject to criticism, mockery, and even outright rejection from social circles or professional environments.
This form of social policing can be particularly damaging, as it not only reinforces the notion that certain behaviors are "uncouth" or "unacceptable," but it also serves to reinforce existing power dynamics. Those with the authority to dictate and enforce the rules of etiquette hold the power to shame and ostracize those who do not conform, effectively disempowering and marginalizing them within the social hierarchy.
Breaking the Cycle: Recognizing Manners as a Tool of Oppression
To truly dismantle the oppressive power of manners, we must first recognize them for what they are: a tool for reinforcing social hierarchies and perpetuating divisions. This requires a critical examination of the cultural and historical roots of etiquette, as well as an acknowledgment of the ways in which these seemingly innocuous codes of conduct can be weaponized to exclude and disempower.
It is also crucial to challenge the notion of universal manners and to embrace the diversity of cultural traditions and behavioral norms. Rather than imposing a singular set of rules, we must create spaces where different forms of etiquette are respected and valued, allowing individuals to express their cultural identities without fear of judgment or marginalization.
Moreover, we must be mindful of the ways in which manners can be used to perpetuate existing power structures and to exclude those who do not conform to the dominant cultural norms. By recognizing and addressing these subtle forms of oppression, we can work towards creating more inclusive and equitable environments, where all individuals feel empowered to participate and contribute without the burden of constantly navigating complex and often conflicting codes of conduct.
Ultimately, the path towards true social harmony and empowerment lies not in the rigid enforcement of manners, but in the cultivation of mutual respect, understanding, and a willingness to embrace diversity. By acknowledging the ways in which etiquette has been used as a tool for division and disempowerment, we can begin to dismantle these oppressive systems and build a more equitable and inclusive society.